We had a monster 40” flat screen in the living room and when it came time to finally upgrade, my wife and I discussed which direction we should go. She wanted a larger flat screen. I wanted a projection system. The “discussion” was long, fierce and horribly one-sided. Yet for every objection she gave, I offered a well-reasoned response.
|Her Objections||My Responses|
|Projectors are too expensive.||720p projectors in the $500 range. We can get a good 1080p/WUXGA projector for under $2,000. Screens sometimes go on sale for $49 for up to 130″. Try finding a 130″ flat panel for that money.|
|The screen won’t be bright enough.||A 3,000 lumens projector is plenty bright for our small room with ambient lighting/windows. But to be fair, at 2,000 lumens, we may need to draw the drapes.|
|Glare from the windows will wash out the image.||Glare off of a glass screen will be worse.|
|60″ is big enough.||Let’s be serious. 100″ is better. And 130″ is amazing.|
|I don’t want a black box hanging in the middle of the room.||It’ll sit on a shelf at the opposite end of the room.|
|It will be too difficult to install.||It takes two people to mount a 60″ flat panel to the wall. One of our kids could put a projector on a shelf.|
|I won’t know how to use the projector.||It works the same way as the flat panel. You press the power button to turn it on.|
I felt so good about my arguments, that I started planning how to rearrange the living room to fit the new projector. Unfortunately, my confidence was misplaced, as we ended up buying a flat screen (wah wah). Here it is.
But, just because I lost the battle, I wasn’t willing to give up on the war. I took up carpentry and built a shelf to go over the new TV. My wife loved it, even adding family memorabilia that we had collected over the years.
What she didn’t notice was the screen mounted on the underside of it (the white bar above the TV running the length of the shelf). Nor did she see the projector sitting on the shelf on the opposite side of the room.
We have had people over many times for SuperBowl parties, NCAA tournaments, USC/UCLA football game, World Cup, etc. We have also hosted movie night for my nephews and nieces, where we would push the couches across the room and lay blankets and pillows on the ground. Everyone loves it.
My wife still maintains that the image size is overly excessive. But that is exactly the point. For the same price, we got a huge screen compared with the flat screen.
Nowadays, we use the projector almost on a nightly basis. Whether it is watching her favorite shows (Dancing with the Stars and So You Think You Can Dance) or playing Dance Central on the Xbox, she loves the larger screen. And when the kids go to sleep, we enjoy our own movie night–something we have not been able to do for years.